I have been browsing in my smoking/barbecuing/grilling cookbooks and came upon this recipe. I made one or two slight modifications in ingredients, but technique and process was as written.
This particular book, "Smoke and Spice", by Cheryl Alters Jamison and Bill Jamison was one that has sat on my bookshelf for years. This recipe spoke to me, hence I gave it a whirl. Oh, man, oh, man, am I ever glad I did. This had to be the BEST BURGER I have 1) ever made, 2) ever tasted!
I was unable to find a web page with the recipe, so I typed it up. Apologies to the Jamison's.
Humdinger Hamburgers
This is the way to one-up uppity neighbors who brag about their grilled hamburgers. Smoking make the ground meat taste like tenderloin.
Wild Willy's Number One-derful Rub
3 T paprika, I used Hungarian
1 T ground black pepper
1 T smoked salt, (he called for just salt, I used alder smoked sea salt)
1 T brown sugar, (he called for just white sugar)
1.5 t chili powder, (I used chipotle)
1.5 t garlic powder
1.5 t onion powder
1/4 t cayenne, (I left it out because of the chipotle)
2 lb "cheapest grade" ground beef, (I used grass-fed 80-20 as it was all I could get, and used 1 lb for the two of us)
1/2 medium onion, chopped fine
3 chopped roasted green chiles, (I used a can of Ortega chopped green chiles, 3 T)
1 t air dried shallots (my addition, not in his recipe)
Basic Beer Mop
6 oz beer
1/4 c cider vinegar
1/4 c water
2 T canola or corn oil
1/4 medium onion, chopped
1 garlic clove minced
1.5 t Worcestershire sauce
1.5 t Wild Willy's Rub from above
I did not use the mop, but in the interest of authenticity, I am including their recipe.
About 1 to 2 hours before you plan to barbecue, combine the rub ingredients in a small bowl. In another bowl, mix together the hamburger, onion, peppers and shallots with your hands. (Be very gentle with the meat, do not over work or your end product will be dry, my addition). For the mixture into 4 thick patties and apply the dry rub thoroughly to all surfaces, reserving at least 1.5 t of the spice mixture for the mop. Cover the patties with plastic and refrigerate them.
Prepare smoker for barbecuing, bringing the temperature to 200° F to 220° F.
Remove the patties from the refrigerator and let them sit at room temperature for 15 minutes.
If you plan to baste the meat, stir the mop ingredients together in a small saucepan and warm over low heat.
Transfer the patties to the smoker and cook for about 1 hour, mopping every 20 in a wood-burning pit, or as appropriate for your style of smoker. (I did not mop, used my pellet smoker.)
Serve the burgers on a toasted bun. Try a bite before reaching for any optional toppings or condiments, all good but less than essential with the richly flavored meat.
(My change up, I seared the burgers in a frying pan when they reached the 135° F mark.)
I thought that this would be okay, enjoyable, but not life changing. This really was the best burger I have ever eaten. If you don't have a smoker, then create one and use it in your oven or buy a stovetop one. You can thank me later!
I had pretzel buns. Next time I will use potato rolls that are squishier. It was really tough getting it into our mouths. The burger is a perfect medium rare all the way through. It was really juicy and amazingly flavorful. It had a bit of a spice kick, and that made me happy. I did put dijon mustard on the bun and nothing else. Followed it up with a tomato and onion salad. The recipe made 2 SUBSTANTIAL burgers, one just over 8 oz, and the second just over 10 oz. You really didn't need anything other than the salad.
This is a true revelation and a keeper of a recipe. It is fairly easy, but not quick. Luckily, one can read, power wash the deck, have a drink, or sit in the sun, (perhaps all four). Let me know via the comments at the end if you tried this and did it ruin all other burger experiences for you!